Sig Rating Thread The other one died years ago and I thought it'd be fun to have sigs/avvies/banners rated by other users. Critism is accepted if said nicely. Rate the sig or whatever ?/10. If not a perfect score please explain why you gave the score you did. Animations are acceptable if the sig is being judged on the actual non-moving sig parts or quality and stuff and not the animation.
My Sigs to Rate:
Okay I'm really not fired up about Archuleta anymore, but this is a good sig.
I'm not completely thrilled with this one but decided to post it anyways.
Woo. Post your own and rate others.
__________________
It's June 2019. I came back to delete my signature of Ryan Ross doing cocaine (not that I am the one who put it there).
Well, for the first one, I'd give it a.. 8/10. It could use a different variation of blue. And for the second one, 9/10. I like the pic, and the sig, but I think that it could use more variations of green too.
Now rate mine! :B
Kinda old, but I still love it. :B
Also one of my favs. :D
I know I should change subject... BUT IT'S IMPOSSIBLE. ;-;
__________________
just came by to say goodbye. Leaving this place for good. Psycho sucks. Bye.
Collar: Yours are really good, but I also think the image is too..blended. 7/10 DM4: I really like your backgrounds, the second one is one of my favorites. 8.5/10.
r8 mine plz you don't have to do all of them..I just couldn't choose which ones I wanted to put. ;_; XD
Collargirl: Nice ones! The first will be 8/10. I think the words could maybe me darker? Or something, so you could see them a bit better. The second one looks perfect, 10/10!
DM4: Very awesome ones. I like the first the best, 10/10! The second one, I don't really like how you can't see all of the words. But its a neat affect on them. 8/10!
Gilly: woa, lotsa sigs xD Since theres so many, I'll pick out two to rate! How about, the fourth one! It really fits togethor, but where it says "Canadiens" I think they could go up a bit? So they don't overlap the 'C'. But they also look pretty neat the way they are. 9/10! And the next to last one is my favorite. It's very unique, and greatly put togethor! 10/10!
Tikey: awsum. 11/10!!!! ;O nah 10/10 xDD
rate mine :B
__________________
Wait, why are you reading my post? why am i posting? why am i asking myself questions? why am i so lame? why dont i just stfu?
Labby, nice one! I really like how you turned everything into that theme. However, maybe pump up the colors just a little bit? I know it's a pirate theme, but still, kinda bland, ya know? 8.5/10. :D
__________________
It's June 2019. I came back to delete my signature of Ryan Ross doing cocaine (not that I am the one who put it there).
Gilly, I LOVE that Paramore one. xD I give it a 9/10.
uhhh...
One of my favorites. My favorite photoshoot as well. I like the font. ONLY thing I don't like is the position of the actual heart, but I saved it and uploaded it and all that when I finally realized I didn't like it there. ):
